Find these products in our Eatontown store!

Picture perfect slabs of chocolate bark chock-full of fresh roasted almonds. This handmade treat is great for gift-giving or for your very own indulgence.

Buttery goodness coated in milk chocolate and hand-rolled in fresh ground almonds. After just one bite, you'll know why it's a bestseller at Criterion. 

Fresh roasted almonds and pure chocolate make our clusters second to none. Available in milk or dark chocolate.

Fresh roasted almonds coated in creamy caramel then covered with the finest milk or dark chocolate. An all-time favorite!

The freshest Granny Smith apples hand-dipped in delicious red candy making them both sweet and crunchy. Available in either plain red candy or red candy hand-rolled in shredded coconut. 

*Seasonal for freshness, call for availability.

Fresh Granny Smith apples hand-dipped in gooey caramel then covered in our signature milk chocolate or hand-rolled in either peanuts or rainbow sprinkles. With so many options, we have a caramel apple for every kind of candy lover.

*Seasonal for freshness, call for availability.

Fresh roasted cashews and pure chocolate make our clusters second to none. Available in milk or dark chocolate.

Fresh roasted cashews coated in creamy caramel then covered with the finest milk or dark chocolate. An all-time favorite!

Smooth, creamy caramel covered in a thick layer of delicious milk or dark chocolate. If you like caramel, you are going to love these.

Honey graham crackers thickly coated in milk and dark chocolate. A real crowd pleaser that is sure to make your taste buds smile.

Approximately 8 pieces per 1/2 lb.

Three layers of rich and creamy chocolate. Hazelnut combined with dark and milk chocolate. An all-time favorite.

If you like rich and creamy, this assortment will be your favorite. 

Approximately 16 pieces per 1/2 lb.

Soft and chewy shredded coconut combined with our signature Criterion chocolate to create these delectable coconut clusters. Available in milk chocolate and dark chocolate.

Classic chocolate and cream-filled sandwich cookies generously covered in our signature milk or dark chocolate. Wash these treats down with a tall glass of milk. 

Moist and chewy sugar-dusted candies that make a perfectly sweet summertime treat. With an assortment of orange, raspberry, lemon and lime, you really can't go wrong.

Approximately 15 pieces per 1/2 lb.

Our homemade fudge is the best fudge you've ever tasted. A perfectly creamy and sweet treat that is available in chocolate, vanilla, chocolate pecan, vanilla pecan, and peanut butter. Simple sinful perfection in each bite.

Nothing tastes better at the end of a meal than glazed apricots half-dipped in creamy chocolate. If you're looking for a delectable and healthy dessert, look no further. Available in milk or dark chocolate. 

Crunchy malted milk centers triple dipped in layers of milk chocolate. Simply the best malted milk balls around!

Solid milk chocolate drops coated in crunchy blue nonpareils for a little pop of color. Whether blue is your favorite, your school or top team's color or you just need a little more cool in your life, our nonpareils are an all-time favorite among all ages.

Solid milk chocolate drops coated in crunchy green nonpareils for a little pop of color. Whether green is your favorite, your school or top team's color or you just need a little more festivity in your life, our nonpareils are an all-time favorite among all ages.

Solid milk chocolate drops coated in crunchy orange nonpareils for a little pop of color. Whether orange is your favorite, your school or top team's color or you just need a little more fun in your life, our nonpareils are an all-time favorite among all ages.

Solid milk chocolate drops coated in crunchy pink nonpareils for a little pop of color. Whether pink is your favorite, your school or top team's color or you just need a little more pretty in your life, our nonpareils are an all-time favorite among all ages.

Solid milk chocolate drops coated in crunchy purple nonpareils for a little pop of color. Whether purple is your favorite, your school or top team's color or you just need a little more of this royal hue in your life, our nonpareils are an all-time favorite among all ages.

Solid milk chocolate drops coated in crunchy red nonpareils for a little pop of color. Whether red is your favorite, your school or top team's color or you just need a little more fire in your life, our nonpareils are an all-time favorite among all ages.

Solid milk chocolate drops coated in crunchy white nonpareils for a little pop of color. Whether white is your favorite, your school or top team's color or you just need a little more bright in your life, our nonpareils are an all-time favorite among all ages.

Solid milk chocolate drops coated in crunchy yellow nonpareils for a little pop of color. Whether yellow is your favorite, your school or top team's color or you just need a little more happy in your life, our nonpareils are an all-time favorite among all ages.

Solid chocolate drops coated in crunchy rainbow nonpareils. An all-time favorite among all ages. Available in both milk and dark chocolate.

Whole glazed orange peel strips covered in either milk or dark chocolate. An irresistible chocolate with a citrus kick.

Fresh roasted peanuts and pure chocolate make our clusters second to none. Available in milk or dark chocolate.

Fresh roasted pecans coated in creamy caramel then covered with the finest milk or dark chocolate. An all-time favorite!

Naturally sweet raisins and pure chocolate make our clusters second to none. Available in milk or dark chocolate.

Fresh, chewy caramel covered with milk or dark chocolate and topped with a pinch of sea salt. Sweet, salty deliciousness in every one inch bite. 

You've tried others, now bite into our creamy mint confection coated in rich dark chocolate and taste the difference.

Our Salt Water Taffy is seashore favorite. Select an assortment of your own from our popular flavors which include chocolate, vanilla, strawberry, orange, lemon, lime, licorice, root beer, banana, and peppermint. These soft and creamy chews will leave you wanting more.

Approximately 29 pieces per 1/2 lb.

An assortment of chocolates with a special message. Assortment includes milk and dark chocolate caramels, raspberry jellies, creams, solids, nuts, and nonpareils.

Our Salt Water Taffy mix contains a flavorful variety including chocolate, vanilla, strawberry, orange, lemon, lime, licorice, root beer, banana, and peppermint. This 12 oz. Waterfront Village box is a great gift for kids, friends or yourself!  

Approximately 42 pieces.