FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

Criterion Chocolates is conveniently located off Route 35 in Eatontown, NJ (just turn at McDonalds).  Our address is 125 Lewis Street and our store hours are 10 a.m. - 5:30 p.m. Monday throught Saturday.  We are open select Sundays surrounding Holidays.  

Chocolates should be stored at room temperature. Avoid sunlight and ambient odors. Do not refrigerate chocolate it may collect condensation and discolor the chocolate.

Yes, we carry a smaller selection of sugar free chocolate in our showcase from which you may choose.  However, the selection of sugar free chocolate is not as wide as the regular milk and dark chocolate we carry.

Our chocolates contain dairy ingredients. Some confections may contain gluten ingredients. Our chocolates are produced in a facility that uses nuts.  Some of our chocolates contain soy lecithin as an emulsifier.

For online orders, we are currently shipping to the Lower 48 States via UPS or USPS. Flat rate shipping fee of $10.95 per address. Free shipping for orders above $79.95 per address.

Yes. For more information please contact us via email info@criterionchocolates.com or call (732) 542-7847.

Chocolates will melt when exposed to temperatures above 70 degrees. Our fudge and salt water taffy are better choices for the summer months. All orders will be shipped Monday through Wednesday from mid-April to mid-September. 

If you are local, we may be able to accommodate overnight shipping of chocolates during the summer months. Please contact us via email info@criterionchocolates.com or call (732) 542-7847.

We accept major credit cards and debit cards including Visa, Mastercard, and American Express.

Yes. Please contact us via email: info@criterionchocolates.com

Yes. For online orders, select in-person pick up at checkout. We will contact you to let you know when your order is ready. You can also call (732) 542-7847 to place your order and arrange a time for pick up. We will bring your order to your car.